ان احترم وجهة نظر جميع الناس اللي ردوا .. بس يا جماعه انا طرحت موضوع علمي بحت وكنت اتمنى الرد بنفس الاسلوب.
وهذي الردود اللي وصلت بالنسبه ليوم الخميس حسب موقع اللجنه. واللي يبي يقطها براس عالم ويطلع منها سالم اهو حر بس الانسان مخير وليس مسير. ومعنى هذا الكلام ان لا يقلد الانسان تقليدا اعمى بل يفكر ويبحث ويقرر بنفسه الصواب من الخطأ.
وانا الحمدالله اني كنت صائم اليوم مو اتباعا لأحد بل عن قناعة ويقين حسب موقع الهلال بالافق واستحالة الرؤيه.
وعيدكم مبارك وعسى الله ان يتقبل منا ومنكم صالح الاعمال
www.moonsighting.com
Thursday, October 11, 2007:
A news has come that Saudis announced Eid to be on Friday, Oct 12. Of course, it is impossible to see the moon in Saudi Arabia on Thursday.
Moonset was before sunset, and angle from sun was less than 6 degrees, when no light from the surface of the moon can come to earth.
Goolam Tegally (MCW member) from Port Louis, Mauritius, reported: Not Seen
There have been no reports of Hilal sighting here in Mauritius to-day, Thursday, 11 October 2007. So we are completing 30 days Ramadhan. We will be celebrating EID on Saturday, 13 October 2007.
Hamza Rijal, (MCW member), from Island of Zanzibar, Africa, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
The Shawal Hilaal was not sighted in tiny island of Zanzibar on 11 of October, therefore we are completing 30 days. The official first day of Shawal in Zanzibar will correspond to Saturday, 13 October, 2007
Yusuf M. Lambat (MCW member), Blantyre, Malawi, reported: Not Seen
No sighting of the crescent. Eid will be celebrated on Saturday 13 October 2007.
Ahmed Mohamed, (MCW member) from Windhoek, Namibia, reported: Not Seen
Moon was not sighted on tonight 11 october 2007, however we will complete 30 day of Ramadaam, and Eid Ul fitr will be on Saturday 13 october 2007.
Dr Abdurrazak Ebrahim (MCW member) from Cape Town, S. Africa, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
At 7.25 pm local time, the official announcement that Ramadaan will be extended to a 30 day month and Eidul Fitr will be observed on Saturday (13 October 2007) in South Africa was made by the elected Hakim and televised on all local TV stations and relayed via airways per South African radio stations. The crescent was not sighted.
A Blessed Eid to all, and especially to Muslim Brothers and sisters, and children, who find themselves in difficult and trying situations and conditions.
Rashid Motala (MCW member) from Durban, South Africa, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
The Hilaal for Shawwal was not sighted anywhere in SA this evening. Saturday (13th Oct.) has been declared Eid-ul-Fitr.
Amara from SaphirNews, France, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
We are the first webmagazine dedicated to islamic information in France I just wanted to inform you that, officialy, Eid el fitr will take place here on Saturday, Oct 13th, Inch'Allah This is the decision of the French Conseil of Muslim Affairs
Jamal Mimouni, Sirius Astronomy Association, Constantine, Algeria, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
It was read on national TV the official communiqué of the National Crescent Committee, stating that:
1-Due to the fact that the crescent was not seen anywhere in Algeria
2-Due to the scientific impossibility of its visibility
the month of Ramadhan will be completed to 30 days, and the Eid will be on Saturday 13 October.
Muhammad Afifi al-Akiti (MCW member) from Oxford, UK, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
Negative sighting. The two of us attempted to perform the obligatory sighting tonight for the UK on 29 Ramadan or Thursday, 11th of October, after Maghrib prayers--in spite of the fact that the crescent is not expected to be visible locally. The local horizon is partly cloudy. We received reports of negative sightings from Morocco, Indonesia and Malaysia tonight. The authorities in Malaysia and Indonesia have declared that the month of Ramadan is to complete its 30 days. There is no news of positive sightings tonight anywhere East to our longitude, which means that those in the UK should try to complete the month of Ramadan with the Tarawih tonight, and that the first day of 'Id al-Fitr should fall on Saturday, 13th of October. 'Id Mubarak!
Muhammed Yasin Qamardeen (MCW member) from Iyana Ipaja, Lagos State, Nigeria, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
The Hilal of shawwal was not visible tonight perharp due heavy cloudy at western sky here in Lagos, at the shore of Atlantic. Besides, report from Bauchi city, Bauchi State and Ilorin, Kwara state were indicative of clear sky and heaavy cloud at the time of magrib respectively. Hence over half of Nigerian muslim will observe their Eid on Saturday.
Muhammad Hafiz (MCW member) from Guyana, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
Myself and the members of Rose Hall Town Masjids and Islamic Center tried to observe the Hilaal after sunset on Thursday, 11th October, 2007 in Guyana. As was predicted from the Hilaal visibility curve no Hilaal was observed. I will InshaAllah, try to observe the Hilaal tomorrow on the 30th day of Ramadan.
Also, the Central Islamic Organization of Guyana has also confirmed non sighting in Guyana via TV on Thursday, 11th October, 2007 in Guyana, thus as predicted by the Hilaal visibility curve, Eid Ul Fitir begins for the majority of Muslims in Guyana on Saturday.
HiMY SYeD (MCW member) from Toronto, Canada, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
The Hilal Committee of Toronto has also determined that since no satisfactory moonsighting has been made, they too are completing a full 30 days of Ramadan and Celebrating Eid al Fitr on Saturday October 13 2007.
Amjed Hashmi from Chicago, IL, reported: Not Seen, 30 days will be completed
In Chicago we had our Hilal Committee meeting to gather the moonsighting information.There was no moonsighting in USA yesterday and hence the Committee has decided to complete 30 days.Eid will be tomorrow.Please find the attached announcement with a request to post this news on your web site.
Sharaaz Khan Qadri (MCW member) from Wilton(Sacramento) California, reported: Not Seen
I went out to look for the crescent on Thursday evening but the Sacramento horizon was overcast and I believe it was the same in the Bay Area. Sighting was not possible from Sacramento/Wilton. In the light of the fact that the moon was not sighted anywhere in the US, our local masjid along with many others accross the nation that started Ramadan on Thursday Sept 13, will complete thirty days and observe Eid ul-Fitr on Saturday October 13.
Mirza Shahid Basravi (MCW member) from Irvine, California, reported: Not Seen
I went to a vantage spot within Irvine, California, where I could see the sun go down to zero degrees without any obstruction. There was a slight haze in the western horizon but not any more than what it was when we spotted the Ramadan New moon. I had started to look for the Moon crescent with my 7 x 35 binocular, even when the sun was between 1 and 0 degrees above the horizon. The sun disappeared by my cell phone watch at 6:21PM. Per all astronomical reports the moon would set within 5 minutes of the sunset. However, I stayed out there till 6:37PM and scoped a wider area; both vertically and horizontally, just in case the astronomical calculation are inaccurate. After all this effort I was unable to spot the new moon crescent on Thursday October 11, 2007.
منو؟